Ace Alliance iGaming Awards 2026
Ace Alliance iGaming Awards 2026
Check out the winners.
See The Winners!
Table Of Content :

EU Court Declines to Rule on Malta’s Bill 55 Compatibility in Gambling Case

trust
Ace Alliance: Delivering Trust Through Expertise
From exclusive events and interviews to real-time market trends, Ace Alliance brings you unbiased, well-informed, and data-driven content. Our editorial team adheres to strict editorial standards, ensuring that the information you receive is not only relevant but also trustworthy.

Built by market experts hosting events since 2023, with our first event in Riga, Latvia gathering over 300 top level iGaming industry executives, Ace Alliance is able to provide you with reliable information from direct interaction with experts and leaders in the sector.
Altay
Altay Celikkaya
Content Manager
Updated:
Reading Time: 2 minutes

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has declared an Austrian court’s request for a preliminary ruling on Malta’s controversial Bill 55 inadmissible, leaving its compatibility with EU law unresolved.

In its 19 November 2026 judgment in Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma, the Court ruled that the questions were not necessary to resolve the underlying dispute involving a litigation funding company and its legal adviser.

EU Court leaves Malta's Bill 55 legal status unresolved, with Malta and EU flags displayed.

Regulation & Compliance

Key Takeaways From the CJEU's Bill 55 Judgment

  • The CJEU rejected the Austrian court’s request as inadmissible

  • Judges did not determine whether Malta’s Article 56A complies with EU law

  • The dispute concerned legal advice provided to a litigation funding company

  • Cross-border enforcement concerns for Malta-licensed gambling operators remain unresolved

How the Spielerschutz Sigma Dispute Reached the Court

Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder, finances claims by players seeking to recover gambling losses from Malta-licensed operators allegedly providing services without the required Austrian authorisation. After obtaining reimbursement judgments in Austria, the company sought to enforce them in Malta.

However, Malta introduced Article 56A of its Gaming Act in June 2023, commonly known as Bill 55, restricting recognition and enforcement of certain foreign judgments against locally licensed gambling operators. The funder had obtained legal advice concluding that the legislation conflicted with EU law and would not prevent enforcement.

When a Maltese court subsequently refused recognition of an Austrian judgment, Spielerschutz Sigma sued its legal adviser in Vienna, seeking compensation for fees and alleged financial losses. The Austrian Commercial Court referred questions concerning Bill 55’s compatibility with EU law to the CJEU.

Why the CJEU Declared the Referral Inadmissible

According to the Court’s official judgment announcement, the relevant question in the Austrian lawsuit was whether the adviser’s opinion was reasonably defensible using the legal information available when it was provided. The Court determined that this assessment, governed by Austrian law, did not require a definitive ruling on Malta’s legislation.

Consequently, the judges found that the requested interpretation of EU law was unnecessary to resolve the dispute. Importantly, the judgment neither upheld nor invalidated Article 56A. It addressed the admissibility of this specific preliminary-ruling request rather than the legislation’s substantive compatibility with EU law.

What the Decision Means for Malta-Licensed Operators

The unresolved legal position remains significant for gambling operators facing player reimbursement claims across European jurisdictions. We previously reported on the European Commission’s objections to Malta’s Bill 55, which raised concerns about judicial cooperation and enforcing foreign judgments.

The latest decision also follows a separate January CJEU ruling involving Malta-licensed operators, addressing applicable law in gambling-related compensation claims. In April 2026, Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou recommended declaring the Spielerschutz Sigma referral inadmissible. He also expressed the non-binding view that Bill 55 would conflict with EU law if its substance were examined. The dispute sits alongside other cross-border proceedings, including the Tipico case concerning national licensing requirements and restitution.

For operators and compliance teams, the ruling leaves legal uncertainty surrounding foreign judgment enforcement unresolved. Future judicial decisions and the European Commission’s separate infringement proceedings remain relevant to assessing potential liabilities.